Thursday Thriller
January 4, 2023
While the last half of winter break had its challenges, there were definitely parts of it that were great! Sharing family pictures helps remind me pause, reflect and find the good.π
Schmidt-Doepker-Ramos-Hallowell Family Photo
My parents are doing better and definitely on the mend. Mom had an MRI yesterday. Come to find out she had compressed a verterbrae when she was trying to get out of bed and slumped down because her legs gave out. Kidney infection is being treated with antibiotics and the back is being treated with some pain meds and rest. π
- All volunteer opportunities need to be listed in the VIP system – that is any event, or project, a teacher/school has that needs volunteers and the teacher/school needs to get the details to the CIS advocate at their school. (CIS advocates will be sending the VIP volunteer opportunity forms to everyone at the school today, if they haven't already.)
- If a teacher has a volunteer that is regular in their classroom they can work with the CIS advocate to set up an opportunity just for them so they can check in/check out
- All volunteers must use the kiosk to check in, every time they volunteer. This should replace paper sign-ins.
Cellphones in Schools: To Ban or Not to Ban
In this Education Gadfly article, Tim Daly (EdNavigator) reports that France and China
have forbidden student cellphone use during the school day, and the U.K. is actively
considering a ban. In the U.S., many K-12 educators, academic leaders, and newspaper
editorials are on board, for these reasons:
- Since around 2012 there’s been an increase in young people’s loneliness, anxiety,
depression, and other mental health problems, coinciding with heavy social media use.
- Cellphones prevent students’ face-to-face socializing in school, and many kids have
lost the art of conversing with peers.
- Even in schools with cellphone restrictions, students find ways to circumvent them; one
study found that 97 percent of teens are on their phones for an average of 43 minutes during the school day.
- Studies show that cellphones distract from learning – even when students aren’t
actually using them – and are contributing to distressingly low student achievement.
Daly looked for adult advocates of the opposite position – that cellphones are relatively benign
and shouldn’t be banned – and couldn’t find arguments worth sharing.
Several different levels of cellphone bans are being considered and implemented, each
with pros and cons:
• Leave cellphones at home – This simplifies enforcement for staff. But there’s been
pushback from parents who want their children to be reachable at all times, including in transit
to and from school, also from cashless students who want to be able to pay for items
electronically before and after school.
• Student cellphone use is not allowed during the school day – This is the most
commonly used policy now, with students leaving their phones in lockers or parking them in
classroom holders under teachers’ supervision, not permitted in bathrooms and during passing
time, lunch, or recess. The downside of this approach is more enforcement responsibility for
staff and the possibility of inconsistency from classroom to classroom.
• No cellphone use during classes – This means phones aren’t on desks, under desks,
streaming music into earbuds, or secretly taking videos of classmates or teachers. The
downside is that phones are still in pockets, purses, or backpacks, constantly distracting
students from learning, and a trip to the bathroom is an opportunity to dive into social media
and messaging. Banning phones during classes is the least popular policy among educators,
says Daly, because it “requires a substantial level of teacher enforcement, which quickly
becomes exhausting. Many teachers simply give up.”
What’s needed, he believes, is a policy that can be consistently enforced, minimizes
hassles, and doesn’t distract from instruction. “Teachers don’t want to spend all day policing
phones,” he says. “It’s awkward. It’s infantilizing. It can escalate. For some kids, having
something cherished taken from them puts them in a very defensive, anxious position. Power
dynamics across lines of difference zoom to the fore. Parents get really angry. Administrators
often won’t back teachers who enforce the administrators’ own policies.”
Another consideration as schools decide what to do about cellphones is the current
trend away from harsh, no-excuses discipline. In the wake of the pandemic, many students are
struggling, fragile, and in need of relationship-building. Attendance is down and a good
number of students aren’t present even when they’re sitting in classrooms. Teachers are
competing for students’ “mindshare,” says Daly. “It’s no fun when half your class isn’t truly
there. Banning cellphones won’t solve that problem.” Schools have also invested in one-to-one
technology, putting tablets or laptops in students’ hands most of the day, and kids are adept at
working around the firewalls to play games and communicate with each other.
In light of these complicating factors, what are schools to do? Daly proposes a four-part
Strategy:
• Invest in pouches with strong magnetic locks so students have their phones with them
but turned off and put away for the whole school day, with convenient unlocking stations at
school exits (Yondr is one company marketing these).
• Insist on consistent enforcement by staff. “Teachers can’t ignore bullying or physical
violence,” he says. “They can’t let kids cheat on state tests. They shouldn’t ignore phones,
either… Hold teachers accountable on performance reviews if they are undermining the
school’s campaign for phone-free learning.”
• Have meaningful penalties when students break the rules, not just giving the phone back at the end of the day, which is when they would get it back anyway. Daly suggests detention or requiring parents to come to school and pick up the phone.
• Ensure that classrooms are “warm, lively, engaging environments where kids can focus
on things worth doing,” he concludes. “Target all barriers to that goal, even if they turn out to
be iPads, bad curriculum materials, boring instruction, negligent classroom management, or
low expectations. If we don’t address those things, how can we blame kids for watching
TikTok in the bathroom? Wouldn’t you do the same?”
“Should Schools Ban Cellphones?” by Tim Daly in Education Gadfly, December 8, 2023
1. Bookmark THE HUB





